-
- CommentAuthoryoxscotty
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009 edited
thoughts? opinions? experiences?
i'm in the market for a new lock and deciding between these two. most of the reviews i've read have put these locks at the same level as one another however the onguard seems to be more prone to jamming. the price difference is pretty enticing and i'm leaning towards the onguard because of it.
thanks in advance!
ps i searched the forums and didn't find any previous threads that answered my question. -
- CommentAuthorthe rabbi
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009
i use the ongaurd pitbull mini and it's awesome. small enough for your pocket or hip pouch, and big enough to lock my front wheel to my rear on a pole. -
- CommentAuthorupthemaiden
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009
I had a friend with an onguard that got stuck while her bike was locked to a pole. I don't remember how we got it off, but we eventually got one side opened just enough to squeeze the top tube out, then twist it off of the pole. Her key was completely stuck in the hole. Sometimes I'll notice my kryptonite is starting to feel a little jammed, but some tri-flo in the key hole and a wire brush to the ends of the U and it feels good as new.
The onguard is slightly bigger than the Kryptonite. My wife had to cut the rubber off of the U to get it to fit in her back pocket, and sometimes it falls out because it doesn't have a good grip without that rubber. I think most guys pants have bigger pockets, but still.
I'm also not so sure if the main cylinder of the onguard locks is hardened steel. I've used a hacksaw to cut off the plastic on the bottom of the old ones, and I've put some pretty good gouges into the metal. no guaruntees, but someone MAY be able to cut through the bottom of that lock with a hacksaw. The entire amount of the kryptonite lock is hardened steel.
The final reason I'll always buy kryptonites, is because when it became public knowledge that you could open bike locks with a bic pen, Kryptonite manned up and offered replacements for all of them. No other companies did that, and even for months after that was known I still saw Masterlocks and every other brand of lock with cylinder keys still on the shelves at local shops. I have a lot of respect for Kryptonite for that one, and I'll always buy their locks. -
- CommentAuthorjayohachen
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009
Kryptonite Fahgettaboudit Mini Lock
Can you put a price on your bike?
Skimp on your tires or seat or seatpost or stem or whatever.
There's a reason why they call it Fahgettaboudit. -
- CommentAuthoryoxscotty
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009
thanks so much so far folks, this is awesome feedback. please keep it coming.
the Fahgettaboudit is way too big for me to carry around. i understand where you're coming from and definitely debated getting one but for the number of times i lock up compared to the number of times i bring my bike in, i think one of the smaller locks will suffice. -
- CommentAuthorgergm
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009
i own the krypto mini u, and use it along with one of their 7' looped cables to secure the saddle and wheels to the frame. i have a bunch of pry marks on my krypto mini from attempted theft.. which means it works, BUT if someone really wanted my bike, they'd take the time to bust any lock open. IMO the krypto mini u is a better buy then the fahgettaboutit...
-
- CommentAuthorupthemaiden
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009
Ottowa doesn't sounds like the kinda place that would have too much of a problem with bike theft, but i've never been there so I don't know. That's a pretty big part of it too. I live in pittsburgh, and to be honest, I could probably tie my bike to a pole with a shoe lace and there's a good chance it'd be there when i came back. Other cities, not so much. I've never registered any of my locks/bikes with kryptonite, but I think if you really wanted to be safe, you'd do better to buy the mini and register it, instead of being lazy and spending more on the fahgettaboutit but not registering it. If I'm taking a bike with quick releases on the wheels I'll take a cable to use with the lock, but otherwise the fact that there's a lock on it is usually a good enough deterrant in my situation. The other important thing, which is semi awful, but I usually take a look at the locks on other peoples bikes around mine, and unless it's another nice bike, it's most likely gonna have a cheap $10 walmart lock on it, and bike theives are probably gonna take the path of least resistance on that one.
All that aside, if I was a bike thief, and saw a bike that was really that nice to be worth the hassle, I'd most likely just take some allen keys and strip the entire frame and leave that hanging there, instead of trying to get through a lock, so again the point kinda turns into how well you locked the bike up, and not so much what brand of lock you have. -
- CommentAuthorgreg
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009
The OnGuard mini I have is great, I use it with a Kryptonite 7' looped cable (for the wheels) and the setup has worked fine.
The lock is light and fits in my back pocket and the cable is coiled on my bars when I'm riding -
- CommentAuthorMAVERICK
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009
i think i am going to invest in the krytonite mini
i got the "New York Chain® w/Evolution series 4 Disc Lock" as a gift and ive used it once im already tired of carrying it around! -
- CommentAuthorterrible_one49
- CommentTimeMar 3rd 2009
I have both the mini Evolution, as well as the Onguard bulldog and have used them both a lot.
Here are the pro's and con's-
Evo Mini- Fits PERFECT in the pocket and is smaller, lighter and I believe made of better metal. Smaller barrel so it's less bulky.
Bulldog-SLIGHTLY larger so although does not fit in ALL back pockets, it does fit around your seat tube/rear wheel easier.
Evo mini- Never had the lock jam or key not work, but after a year of use it seems to be getting slightly more finicky. This could go for all locks.
Bulldog- Never jammed and works smooth, but I have not used it nearly as much as the Evo. However, it comes with FIVE KEYS! Why does one lock need five keys? I have no clue.
Evo mini-Everything is metal except for a rubber sleeve around the U and a orange sleeve on the barrel.
Bulldog- The whole barrel is metal I'm sure, but it's contained within a large plastic housing. I would like to see what's inside this plastic housing, but cannot get it off and don't want to risk ruining the lock.
So, I personally trust the Evo mini just because it has not failed me and more people use it, however I have been told by many people that they like the bulldog. But Kryptonite has a longer reputation with making locks and seems to have invested more research+development in their products.
I always use a cable for my wheels also. -
- CommentAuthoryoxscotty
- CommentTimeMar 4th 2009
once again, thanks so much for all the time and efforts put into giving me great insight. hopefully others will benefit from this too!
i've decided to go for the evo mini...mostly because of the ongoing research put into the locks and dedication they have to building a respected product. their reputation is unbeatable too. on a sidenote, they're also the lock the bikes shops here in ottawa have in stock.
ottawa is a decently safe place to lock up your bike...well, at least there's certainly worse. the biking community is fairly small as everyone drives here and/or is a complete government-employed idiot. -
- CommentAuthorupthemaiden
- CommentTimeMar 4th 2009
Terrible one- I know it's long so you may not have gotten through it, but I went over some of that stuff in my post. Just drop some tri-flow in the keyhole of your kryptonite and twist the key around a little, it'll go back to feeling perfect. The plastic stuff comes off fine, it is a pain though, but it's just a metal cylinder like the kryptonite, still a little bigger though. Use any combination of hacksaw, hammer, chisel, and whatever else you have laying around to get it off. It takes a while.
Maverick- I used to have one of those chains and loved it. Only used when occassionally when i felt there was a reason for carrying it. The last time I thought there was a use for it was when my friends stolen mtn bike started being seen around downtown. I checked it out once and it was locked up with the cheapest peice of chain and a little key lock, and was being ridden around by some crackhead. I brought the chain and my mini bolt cutters to work, and had a friend call me when he saw the bike again. I walked over, locked it up with my chain on my break, and planned to come back over lunch to cut off his chain, and return it to it's rightful owner. I later got a phone call from my friend who said he came outside, went back in, complained to security, they watched the security video, and sent maintenance out to cut off my $90 chain! and handed the bike back to the crackhead theif who stole my friends bike. I haven't seen it downtown again. Someday I'd like to have another chain, and if I ever see the crackhead riding that bike again I'm tackling him and throwing him in the river. -
- CommentAuthoryoxscotty
- CommentTimeMar 4th 2009
he'd appreciate being thrown in the river, it'd be a bath! -
- CommentAuthorgreg
- CommentTimeMar 4th 2009
hahah lot of good that $90 chain did if security could cut it that fast -
- CommentAuthorgergm
- CommentTimeMar 5th 2009
that is one crazy story. -
- CommentAuthorlatron
- CommentTimeMar 5th 2009
The biggest, heaviest Fahgettaboutit -- totally worth it. When I look at a regular Kryptonite now, much less any other U-lock, I shudder. -
- CommentAuthorstinky pete
- CommentTimeMay 14th 2009
Posted By: greghahah lot of good that $90 chain did if security could cut it that fast
Is there any bike lock or chain that can stand up to an angle grinder with a cutting disk? -
- CommentAuthorthe rabbi
- CommentTimeMay 14th 2009
Posted By: stinky pete
rhetorical?Posted By: greghahah lot of good that $90 chain did if security could cut it that fast
Is there any bike lock or chain that can stand up to an angle grinder with a cutting disk? -
- CommentAuthorNash
- CommentTimeMay 14th 2009
the kryptonite new york locks are sweeet for sure but a $25 pitbull mini u works fine for my area....plus it has a $2500 theft protection warranty which is more than enough for me -
- CommentAuthoreaglerock
- CommentTimeMay 14th 2009
Posted By: upthemaidenThe last time I thought there was a use for it was when my friends stolen mtn bike started being seen around downtown. I checked it out once and it was locked up with the cheapest peice of chain and a little key lock, and was being ridden around by some crackhead. I brought the chain and my mini bolt cutters to work, and had a friend call me when he saw the bike again. I walked over, locked it up with my chain on my break, and planned to come back over lunch to cut off his chain, and return it to it's rightful owner. I later got a phone call from my friend who said he came outside, went back in, complained to security, they watched the security video, and sent maintenance out to cut off my $90 chain! and handed the bike back to the crackhead theif who stole my friends bike.
First of all, to clarify: In the second-to-last sentence, when you say "he came outside", you mean "the crackhead came outside/went back in/complained to security", not "my friend came outside/went back in/complained to security", right?
This may be the most important reason to file a report with the police. When you take vigilante action like this, you're a lot more likely to get law enforcement (or quasi-law enforcement, like these building security rent-a-cops) to either back you up or let your vigilante act play out if you've informed them that you've taken this step, and that the law is already involved in the matter. Let's look at a few scenarios:
1) Crackhead locks up bike. upthemaiden locks up bike in vigilante move. upthemaiden informs building security that he believes bike to be his friend's stolen bike, reported to Pittsburgh PD in Case Number #123456. Crackhead returns, finds bike locked with strange second lock. Crackhead hollers bloody murder to building security, who now have a problem to deal with: Who actually owns this stupid bike? The fastest way to dump responsibility on someone else is to get the police involved, since building security has been informed of a valid case number, which proves that someone outside the room might check up on what they do. Building security probably doesn't get as far as viewing security tape at all, until the police show up.
2) Crackhead locks up bike. upthemaiden locks up bike in vigilante move. upthemaiden leaves without informing anyone of what he's done. Crackhead returns, finds bike locked with strange second lock. Crackhead hollers bloody murder to building security, who now have a problem to deal with: How to shut the yelling guy up? There are two locks on the bike, and building security has no reason to assume that the person who originally locked it up isn't the legal owner. So they look at the tape, which shows Crackhead locking up the bike. Later on the video, upthemaiden comes around and tosses a second lock/chain on the bike, to prevent Crackhead from unlocking the bike and spiriting off. But building security doesn't know that Crackhead stole the bike, because nobody's told them that. Even if someone had said "that bike was locked up by a thief, so I've tossed a second lock on it so it stays there until we can get this sorted out", it's just he said/she said. In those situations, it's a "possession is 90% of the law" issue, unless there's some convincing point of evidence on Locker #2's side - like a stolen bike report with a case number. From the video, it looks like upthemaiden is the thief, and he's preventing the presumed-by-building-security rightful owner from taking his bike, so that upthemaiden can come and crack the original lock/do a little thievin' at his leisure. This version is only heightened by the fact that upthemaiden, if frisked, would have had a bolt cutter on his person.
Yeeesh!
In this scenario, the fastest way for building security to dump responsibility on someone else is to presume that the perspective of the video is the only relevant perspective: To cut off the second chain, and allow the person who locked the bike up in the first place to unlock it, and be on his merry way.
maiden, let me assure you that I think your perception was almost certainly right: Crackhead stole your friend's bike, and imagined he had a get out of jail free card in his pocket, so that his ill-gotten gains should remain his forever. -
- CommentAuthorbionnaki
- CommentTimeMay 14th 2009
I do not trust onguard locks -- any of them. they do not produce a wide number of key/lock combinations. I heard a number of 1 out of 10 keys will work in their locks. And my onguard key happened to work in a friend's friend's u-lock one night when we were drinking and talking bikes. We had a "lets test this" moment and it worked.
I am supporter of kryptonite now.
I also recommend the fahgettiboudit mini u-lock. If they're too expensive at your shop, ebay seller tough-locks @ http://shop.ebay.com/merchant/tough-locks has them for $65 bucks + free shipping. And if you're worried about the weight, you shouldnt carry them in your bag -- just put the lock into your belt or buy one of those fabric horse holsters for 15 bucks. you wont wont notice the weight once you're riding if it's not on your back. I'll put up with these minor issues in exchange for the strength of the lock vs. the evo mini - a fine lock, but not quite as fine as the fahgettiboutdit mini. -
- CommentAuthorstinky pete
- CommentTimeMay 14th 2009
Posted By: the rabbi
Posted By: stinky pete
rhetorical?Posted By: greghahah lot of good that $90 chain did if security could cut it that fast
Is there any bike lock or chain that can stand up to an angle grinder with a cutting disk?
Not at all; I simply have not found anything that I couldn’t cut through with an angle grinder with a thin cutting disk on it. I don’t steel bikes, but if I did it seems to me that a portable angle cutter would work on just about anything that I have seen a bike locked up with... -
- CommentAuthorhenrydec1
- CommentTimeMay 15th 2009
i have a onguard bulldog mini u. i pulled off all the extra plastic, its probably a pound lighter and it feels way more comfortable in my belt. i like it and it was cheaper then a kryptonite mini. but probably not as strong. what it does have is if you clip one side of the lock its still locked because it has locks on both sides. from what i have heard about the kryptonite mini is if you clip one side you can pull off the u because it has a lock on only one side.
-
- CommentAuthorthe rabbi
- CommentTimeMay 15th 2009
Posted By: stinky pete
i don't think anything would stand up to an angle grinder. anything.Posted By: the rabbi
Posted By: stinky pete
rhetorical?Posted By: greghahah lot of good that $90 chain did if security could cut it that fast
Is there any bike lock or chain that can stand up to an angle grinder with a cutting disk?
Not at all; I simply have not found anything that I couldn’t cut through with an angle grinder with a thin cutting disk on it. I don’t steel bikes, but if I did it seems to me that a portable angle cutter would work on just about anything that I have seen a bike locked up with... -
- CommentAuthorAaron C
- CommentTimeMay 15th 2009
Posted By: the rabbi
Posted By: stinky pete
i don't think anything would stand up to an angle grinder. anything.Posted By: the rabbi
Posted By: stinky pete
rhetorical?Posted By: greghahah lot of good that $90 chain did if security could cut it that fast
Is there any bike lock or chain that can stand up to an angle grinder with a cutting disk?
Not at all; I simply have not found anything that I couldn’t cut through with an angle grinder with a thin cutting disk on it. I don’t steel bikes, but if I did it seems to me that a portable angle cutter would work on just about anything that I have seen a bike locked up with...
except for a u lock made out of a string of a million quotes
1 to 25 of 25

