Quantcast
velospace is about bikes and the people who ride them buy / sell photos random












    • CommentAuthortdubs
    • CommentTimeAug 27th 2009
     
    this may sound stupid but here goes...

    i really like the look of the classic track quill stems. my pista has a chris king threadless headset. is there a stem i can buy with the same look (similar look to the Nitto pearl or something) or do i need to buy a new headset and fork if i want to achieve this look? Any reviews on the quill adapters?
    • CommentAuthorthe rabbi
    • CommentTimeAug 27th 2009
     
    Posted By: tdubsthis may sound stupid but here goes...

    i really like the look of the classic track quill stems. my pista has a chris king threadless headset. is there a stem i can buy with the same look (similar look to the Nitto pearl or something) or do i need to buy a new headset and fork if i want to achieve this look? Any reviews on the quill adapters?
    new fork and headset needed. the quill adapters change threaded to threadless. nothing changes threadless to threaded.
    • CommentAuthorSkidMark
    • CommentTimeAug 27th 2009 edited
     
    With a Chris King Headset you can buy just the threaded parts you need. You don't need a whole new headset. You will need a threaded fork though.
  1.  
    What SkidMark said is true. You can also get your thread less fork threaded.
  2.  
    To do it right - safely - you would need to purchase a threaded fork and headset. And the stem, for that matter. Say $120,less if you can find some used parts, more if you want quality. You could try threading your existing fork, but it will not decrease your costs much, if at all. You could sell your fork ($30?), headset ($80?), and stem (I don't know what it is, so...?) and make some money back, of course.

    That said, you could use a seatpost clamp to hold your fork in place. Sheldon Brown did something similar, though for a different reason.

    Since your fork is 1" already, the quill will fit without issue, and the clamp should hold up. But if the clamp did fail, the best you could hope for is the stem keeping your fork in place without fucking up the headtube. I think it's a big gamble for such a small benefit.

    You're better off buying a used threaded fork having Kilo (which means an older one), or something else used, if you really want a quill.
  3.  
    Posted By: SkidMarkWith a Chris King Headset you can buy just the threaded parts you need.

    Totally true, I didn't think about that. I think the 2nut conversion kit is like $35.
    Threading a threadless fork at your LBS (or whoever they take it to to do this) may not be cheap.
    • CommentAuthortdubs
    • CommentTimeAug 27th 2009 edited
     
    Posted By: SkidMarkWith a Chris King Headset you can buy just the threaded parts you need. You don't need a whole new headset. You will need a threaded fork though.



    cool, thanks... didn't know that!

    and Suicide_doors, the "right" way appeals to me much more than than make-shift version.

    thanks for the tips
  4.  
    Yeah, I charge about 35 bucks to thread a fork. Some other shops in town charge about 60 bucks. It can be pretty expensive.

    Is it just the look of a quill stem you want? There is a reason not too many companies use threaded stuff any more, It works fine but thread less stuff is just a lot easier in my opinion.
  5.  
    I don't think anyone would argue with threadless being easier. It weighs less, too. But I do like the look of threaded stems on lugged steel bikes. IMHO standard TIG frames don't look much better either way.
    • CommentAuthorgelpicorp
    • CommentTimeAug 27th 2009
     
    yeah, i was quoted 30 bucks once for a half inch of new thread. i shudder to the what an lbs might charge to extend the threads of a bike island kilo tt frame low enough to cut to fit properly.
    • CommentAuthorSkidMark
    • CommentTimeAug 27th 2009
     
    You'd cut it a little closer to the length you need before you start threading it.

    If you knew what the die and the die handle cost, you'd understand why it costs so much to thread a fork.
    • CommentAuthorthe rabbi
    • CommentTimeAug 27th 2009
     
    Posted By: SkidMarkYou'd cut it a little closer to the length you need before you start threading it.

    If you knew what the die and the die handle cost, you'd understand why it costs so much to thread a fork.
    indeed. that thing is crazy pricey and you need to supplement the cost.
    • CommentAuthortdubs
    • CommentTimeAug 28th 2009
     
    ok.... thanks for the info.

    my original post comes from not only my desire for aesthetics but also, I just don't like my current stem (too long). because swapping out the fork and headset seems to be a pain in the ass, what do you (forum members) think about the use of a shim? my steerer tube is 1" and after a bit of research, i've come to realize that the majority of threadless set-ups out there are 1-1/8"... or at least in the brands i was looking at. Are these shims a practical, long-term answer or do they just "make it work"? And other Pista owners... what do you use?
    • CommentAuthorkaaos
    • CommentTimeAug 28th 2009
     
    Posted By: suicide_doors...But I do like the look of threaded stems on lugged steel bikes. IMHO standard TIG frames don't look much better either way.


    Agree... I know it's matter of taste but for me the old skool quill stem is the way to go. I somehow always had a feeling that stem is a part on the bike that will make or break your bike when it comes to aesthetics. Quill stems are so elegant and simple and look so good on steel lugged frames.
  6.  
    Posted By: tdubsAre these shims a practical, long-term answer or do they just "make it work"?

    Stem and handlebar shims are very commonly used and, if they are installed correctly, will work just the same as the right size part without a shim. I don't know anyone who has had an issue with a real shim, just don't use copper pipe or a beer can or ... what'd Republic use? Cardboard?

    Cinelli makes a few 1" threadless stems. As do Deda and Ritchey, NOS Salsa if you can find one..
    Ben's somehow got Nitto to make a 1" threadless track stem for them. I think they're ugly as sin.


    Anyway, you're better off shimming.
    • CommentAuthorLyKqiD
    • CommentTimeAug 28th 2009
     
    Cardboard ha!

    C'mon the sweet cinelli alter is 1'' threadless. I can sell you mine, and I'll even include the cowgirl porn insert for free.
    But seriously, you are better off getting a shim, your selection increases by like 500%.

    Posted By: SkidMarkIf you knew what the die and the die handle cost, you'd understand why it costs so much to thread a fork.


    I can understand the price because it is nickel plated on top of already being high grade steel, but is the life of the die really that short to justify the absurd prices?
    • CommentAuthorSkidMark
    • CommentTimeAug 28th 2009 edited
     
    I have search high and low for a different manufacturer of this die. Park charges an arm and a leg because they can.


    Nitto makes a fillet brazed chrome plated chromoly stem that looks a little better than the one pictured above.


    *EDIT* McMaster-Carr (industrial supply house, like Grainger) sells a 1" 24tpi die for $75.21

    Park sells theirs for $126.
 


about, FAQ & policies | contact | blog | status | resources | site map | graphic design
© 2005-2009 velospace. All Rights Reserved.